12 frames is a generous enough margin when pokes come out faster than it. (Character dependent) I wasn't including a jip which basically forces your opponent to stand. And scorpions high/low mixup? Easy. Block low and when you see him go for B2 you can easily react to that. Thats like saying you can't react to jax's overhead smash. Again I'm not calling anyone out, just have to disagree with you on this point.
I think you partially misunderstand what I'm saying. You have good intentions, but this above post is written from the magical world of Theoryland, a place that way, waaaay too many posts on TYM come from. Everyone seems to think that Perfect Legend's reflexes are somehow commonplace, when they're probably more like 1 in 10,000.
Yes, there are moves faster than 12 frames, but that is not a "generous enough margin." It's
1/5th of a second. What I'm saying is that
as a human being, you literally cannot consistently react to that time frame. At
best you can try and anticipate it. People saying anything other than that is theory fighter garbage. Again, there is a reason that
no one punishes that string in competitive play: because in the real world,
you cant.
Jax's overhead smash takes half a second to come out.
That is more along the lines of standard human reaction times, which is why it can be fuzzy guarded: your brain has juuust enough time for you to recognize the distinct animation, release block, and fuzzy guard it at the last moment. And even still, watch tournament play - people do not always block it.
Please do not mention Scorpion's low/overhead mixup. "Easy?" If it was easy, Slips wouldn't be able to run that 50-50 vortex continually. The two moves are essentially the
exact same frames, 17 and 18. Both of them come out in
less than 1/3rd of a second. Humans are
not able to react to it... that's why it
works.
Go back and listen to the first Kombat Tomb Podcast that Slips was on, there is a golden nugget of truth in there:
16bit: "People are saying you can fuzzy guard the vortex."
Slips: "That's absolutely ridiculous."
16bit: "Everyone on the forums says you can react to the overhead."
Slips: "Well, everyone's fucking stupid."